...

DiogenesKynikos

2501

Karma

2019-05-23

Created

Recent Activity

  • The fact that the 1973 war only occurred in Egyptian and Syrian territory actually had a major impact on how other other countries reacted to it.

    Even the US - Israel's main backer - basically treated Egyptian and Syrian war aims as legitimate.

    There is a widespread belief that Israel would have used nuclear weapons if the Syrians and Egyptians had broken through to Israeli territory, and that this was one of the major American motivations for resupplying the Israelis during the war.

  • You're saying that the US embassy in Moscow doesn't know how Russian politicians and military figures think, and is full of useful idiots.

    Another theory is that the US embassy has constant contact with Russian political and military figures, is very familiar with how they think, and accurately reported their views back to DC in order to help the US government formulate its foreign policy.

    Ironically, I think you're the one who has swallowed a narrative hook, line and sinker.

  • Based on the US State Department cables that Wikileaks released all the way back in 2010, Russian fear of NATO expansion into Ukraine was not just a talking point.

    Internal State Department cables from the embassy in Moscow say that entire Russian security and political establishment viewed it as a critical national security threat.

    In particular, take a look at this cable: https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/08MOSCOW265_a.html. Here's an excerpt:

    > Ukraine and Georgia's NATO aspirations not only touch a raw nerve in Russia, they engender serious concerns about the consequences for stability in the region. Not only does Russia perceive encirclement, and efforts to undermine Russia's influence in the region, but it also fears unpredictable and uncontrolled consequences which would seriously affect Russian security interests. Experts tell us that Russia is particularly worried that the strong divisions in Ukraine over NATO membership, with much of the ethnic-Russian community against membership, could lead to a major split, involving violence or at worst, civil war. In that eventuality, Russia would have to decide whether to intervene; a decision Russia does not want to have to face.

    There are warnings throughout the cable that Russia may decide to invade Ukraine over the issue of NATO enlargement. In other words, the claim that this is just a Russian talking point is itself just a talking point.

  • Since it developed nuclear weapons, Israel has never been invaded by a foreign country. Israel launched the 1967 war, and in 1973, Egypt only attacked occupied Egyptian territory. Same for Syria.

  • > Do you trust humans with the ability to judge the situation and the freedom to decide to run a red light if they think it's safe?

    Absolutely not.

    > For people like me, it's a matter of basic human dignity. I want to be a human with the capacity for judgement and the power to act on it.

    Your human dignity does not require you to be able to run red lights when you think it's okay.

    This is libertarian ideology taken to the extreme.

HackerNews