Their argument is that, when you try to make value judgements on human life using some mystical single element, you are failing at the first hurdle. Just like MLK said, judge men based on the content of their character, not on the basis of their skin.
You construed that as "Be ashamed of your biological strengths." Just kinda weird.
I don't have a problem with more obvious failures. My problem is when the LLM makes a credible claim with its generated text that turns out to have some minor issue that catches me a month later. Generally I have to treat LLM responses as similar to a random comment I find on Reddit.
However, I'm really happy when an LLM provides sources that I can check. Best feature ever!